Revisiting “The Trouble with Tribal (Fusion)”
About every two to three months, dancers on a discussion board somewhere are debating about what IS tribal anyway? I wrote a blog entry last spring to explain what I think makes a performance “tribal” and why it could be defined as such. Since then, this entry has become a reference for dancers around the world, and I’m honored to say that Sharon Moore, a dancer I respect very much and co-director of inFusion Tribal Dance Company, has republished this entry on her own website about tribal bellydance.
I’ve reposted this entry because it seems to be one of my most popular. And, I’d like to hear from you what you think of my pontifications. Do you think the characteristics I’ve identified hold true? What do you see as the defining characteristics of tribal bellydance?
“The Trouble with Tribal (Fusion)” (below the cut).
I think tribal belly dance is going through a bit of a crisis right now. The problem? So many new dancers and so little definition of tribal’s identity. With the explosion of soloists dressing up like The Indigo and posting videos of themselves on YouTube, I feel like these dancers don’t know where their roots lie. With so many dancers out there without the resources or instructors to learn American Tribal Style (ATS)–the root of “tribal fusion bellydance”–I see the misconceptions and innocent ignorance going global. Dancers without access to ATS classes will call themselves “tribal fusion” and yet despite their costuming, they dance like oriental/cabaret dancers. It’s like watching a hip hop performance by a dancer in a ballet tutu… and calling herself a ballerina.
- Arms and hands: floreos (ATS-style), high elbows, and strong ATS (flamenco-inspired) arms.
- Upper body posture: A lifted chest, using the muscles in the upper back. A relaxed upper body is more casual, less stylized, and, frankly, more oriental/cabaret.
- Use of classic American Tribal Style steps, integrated into a routine and not just thrown in to fulfill the “tribal” requirement.
- Open facial expression. True ATS dancers smile. Tribal fusion doesn’t require a frown.
- A sense of grounding into the floor. Tribal is inherently earthy.
Note that “locking”, “popping”, and “ticking” are not mentioned. These are breakdance/hip hop movements that many tribal fusion dancers have integrated into their performances. These robotic and staccato movements are not essentially tribal, nor are they essentially belly dance. I have seen many cabaret and oriental dancers integrate these movements into their performances, and yet they still remain essentially cabaret because they lacked the other above mentioned characteristics. Popping, locking, ticking, and strobing are part of the “fusion” of “tribal fusion bellydance.” I’m surprised at how many people I encounter who believe that these are essential to tribal style bellydance.
This also goes for the recent “vintage” trend that is so hot right now (and when done tastefully, can be stunning!). Neo-Victorian/Edwardian/Roaring 20s/burlesque-inspired costuming does not make a dancer “tribal fusion.” As beautiful as the costuming may be, it, in and of itself, is not essentially tribal.
A costume does not make a dancer tribal. If a costume made a dancer “cabaret”, then Carolena Nericcio’s performance in San Francisco Beledi would be cabaret… and when you see this performance, it’s SO tribal. (I wish I could find a screen capture online, but I’m not finding one.)
There are a few things that I feel like should be left out of a “tribal fusion bellydance” performance because I feel that they are contrary to the essence of American Tribal Style. These, of course, are only my personal opinions:
- Cabaret facial expressions
- Lifting the hair with the hands
- Suggestive movements such as wide hip circles a la Dina.
- Wild shoulder shimmies. ATS dancers do perform shoulder shimmies, yet they are subtle and “quiet”.
Lastly, I believe that anyone who calls themselves a “tribal fusion bellydancer” absolutely MUST have studied with authentic American Tribal Style instructors. In this, I would expect anyone who calls themselves “tribal fusion” would be able to dance with others who know American Tribal Style and perform a decent group improvisation. If you’ve never studied American Tribal Style, what are you doing calling yourself tribal fusion?